Deflation vs Inflation

I recently read an analysis that made the argument for deflation rather than inflation. The analyst’s point was that the recently deflated credit bubble has resulted in over-capacity in all sectors of the economy. And this is a global phenomenon, not just a US problem. There are now too many factories, too many ships, too many trains, too many trucks, too many malls and retail shops of all varieties. Over the past few years it was just too easy to get the credit (debt) to build more and more. So if we go back to the economic basics of supply and demand, when there is too much supply something has to happen to either decrease the supply or increase the demand. This analyst makes the argument that prices will decline in order to stimulate demand, hence price deflation. And quite honestly, we are seeing this in many areas. Real estate and stock prices have been in decline, as we all know. There are lots of sales going on in the retail sector, airline ticket prices and hotel room prices are also in decline. The soft demand for these items has resulted in lower prices. The question to ask, however, is how far can this go? How long can it last? Is it of a magnitude that could possibly offset the government’s massive borrowing and spending?

Here’s the thing, this price deflation doesn’t happen by itself, without any corresponding effects that can be felt elsewhere in the overall economy. Sadly, a large percentage of the goods and services that the US economy is made up of have their origins overseas. Whether we are talking about Middle East oil or trinkets from China, so much of our economy results in US dollars going overseas. And, as I’ve already explained, many of those dollars end up coming back to purchase US Treasuries to keep the government running. So, let’s stipulate that the deflationary effects do happen. That will mean that fewer dollars go overseas. That will mean that fewer dollars are available to fund the activities of the US government. As we’ve seen, this will put upward pressure on interest rates. The Federal Reserve will be tempted to buy up the excess Treasuries in order to keep interest rates down, but that will be a big red flag to the foreign holders of US debt that the dollar is being debased. So in spite of what the Fed desires, interest rates will have to go up to attract buyers for the Treasuries that go up to auction. Higher interest rates will put even more downward pressure on the economy, resulting in less economic activity. The cycle will reinforce itself. So in this scenario we see price deflation, higher interest rates and higher unemployment. But does this lead to inflation?

The believers in big government, which essentially are the members of both political parties (Republicans and Democrats both believe that government action is called for to solve our economic ills, they differ only in the magnitude of the action they propose) will naturally turn to more and more government intrusion into our lives. These government handouts will have to be funded by debt and that will increasingly be supported by the creation of dollars by the Federal Reserve. The dollar will become less and less desirable to foreign companies and governments, which means that more and more of them will be required in order to purchase goods and services from those foreign companies and governments. That, my friends, will be inflationary. And by the time we reach that point in the drama that is unfolding before us there will be no stopping it.

So I’ve made the argument for both deflation and inflation. The big question is which force will win the tug-of-war? I’m betting on inflation. Why? For a couple of reasons. One, the loss of US dollar purchasing power is a nearly uninterrupted trend since the creation of the Federal Reserve in 1913 (see the chart from a couple of posts ago). This is the natural trend for fiat currencies (currency that only has value because a government says it has value – fiat is Latin for “let it be done”). They seek their intrinsic value, which is zero. What complicates the situation today is the fact that every currency in the world is a fiat currency. So we are privileged to watch this global race to the bottom, which I believe the US will win because we have the political will to achieve this goal (sadly, this is not a good thing). Two, inflation will win because the US Government has only two options with respect to the massive debt it is raising. They can either default or they can inflate.

Default would be quick, enormously painful and globally disruptive. But it would also be effective, in two ways. The criminals responsible for the pain will be evident to all (I’m talking about the US politicians who trigger the default). They’ll never hold another public office, they’ll go down in history as the criminals they are and they might very likely suffer prosecution from several plaintiffs, if not actually be in physical danger. And, after the mess of default is cleaned up the US dollar will be out of the position of being the world’s reserve currency. That will result in a complete inability of the follow-on government to pursue similarly destructive public policies. We’ll be forced to live within our means, which will be much smaller than we’re used to, by the way.

On the other hand, inflation will allow the current political criminals to continue living in their imagined splendor. As long as inflation doesn’t get too far out of control everything will appear to be “fine” and “normal”. Since inflation preserves the political status quo it is the option to bet on. Quite frankly, I am hoping for mild inflation instead of Zimbabwe style inflation. If inflation were to get out of hand the end result for the US will look very much like the default option. But in either case hard currencies will do well, i.e., a store of physical commodities. I urge you to re-read these past several posts. Think about everything I’ve said. Consider what a proper response to current events should be, particularly as it relates to your savings. Do you really want your savings to be in a stack of pathetic, worthless slips of paper? Shouldn’t you consider putting at least a small portion in something tangible?